CIVIL RIGHTS ORGANIZATION ALLEGES MAJOR TELEHEALTH PROVIDERS EXCLUDE DEAF AND HARD OF HEARING COMMUNITIES NATIONWIDE

PR Newswire
Today at 7:16pm UTC

CIVIL RIGHTS ORGANIZATION ALLEGES MAJOR TELEHEALTH PROVIDERS EXCLUDE DEAF AND HARD OF HEARING COMMUNITIES NATIONWIDE

PR Newswire

Equal Rights Center lawsuits claim MedStar, VitaLink, and Sesame fail to provide ASL interpretation and/or live captioning for d/Deaf and hard of hearing patients

WASHINGTON, Nov. 19, 2026 /PRNewswire/ -- Today, the Equal Rights Center (ERC) announced lawsuits against three telehealth providers—MedStar Health, Inc. (MedStar), VitaLink Telehealth LLC (VitaLink), and Sesame, Inc. (Sesame)—alleging that they fail to provide effective communication for d/Deaf* and hard of hearing individuals. Specifically, the complaints—which were filed in D.C. Superior Court—allege that MedStar excludes deaf and hard of hearing patients by not offering live captioning for telehealth visits, VitaLink excludes Deaf patients by not offering American Sign Language (ASL) interpretation, and Sesame excludes both groups by not offering ASL interpretation or live captioning.

ERC logo

"After ERC members reported concerns about telehealth accessibility, we conducted civil rights testing that identified wide-ranging violations of accessibility requirements designed to ensure effective communication for d/Deaf and hard of hearing people," remarks ERC Executive Director Kate Scott. "Telehealth promises to make medical care more accessible, but our investigation found that providers are effectively closing their doors to d/Deaf and hard of hearing patients."

Through the complaints, ERC alleges that MedStar, VitaLink, and Sesame violate the D.C. Human Rights Act by discriminating against people with disabilities and the D.C. Consumer Protection Procedures Act by falsely claiming to be accessible. While the lawsuits are based in Washington, D.C., the cases have far-reaching implications. MedStar conducted more than 500,000 telehealth visits in Fiscal Year 2025 for patients across D.C., Maryland, and northern Virginia. VitaLink serves 15 states plus Washington, D.C. Sesame operates in all 50 states plus Washington, D.C. and has reportedly treated more than 500,000 patients.

Accessible health care is of critical importance to people with disabilities. Telehealth visits give patients the ability to see medical providers online without the burden of traveling to an office. However, for d/Deaf and hard of hearing individuals, a telehealth visit is only as accessible as the platform on which it takes place.

Deaf individuals who communicate using ASL cannot participate in telehealth visits conducted in English unless an ASL interpreter is present. Likewise, deaf and hard of hearing individuals who rely on live captioning cannot effectively participate in telehealth visits without it. ASL interpretation is not an appropriate substitute for live captioning, nor is live captioning an appropriate substitute for ASL interpretation.

Effective communication is especially important in medical settings. Visits often involve precise and nuanced conversations about a patient's symptoms, medical history, treatment options, and follow-up care. Patients have a right to participate fully in these conversations with their providers and make informed decisions, but that is often impossible for d/Deaf and hard of hearing individuals without proper accommodations.

Law firm Handley Farah & Anderson is representing ERC in the three lawsuits. Partner Martha Guarnieri comments, "Telehealth offers a lot of potential benefits, but it's useless to millions of patients if it's not accessible. We're proud to work with ERC to ensure d/Deaf and hard of hearing folks have equal access to these platforms."

The complaint against MedStar is available here.

The complaint against VitaLink is available here.

The complaint against Sesame is available here.

CONTACT:
Nick Adjami, Communications & Engagement Manager
Equal Rights Center
nadjami@equalrightscenter.org, (202) 370-3219

*The uppercase "Deaf" refers to a particular group of people who share a language (sign language) and a culture, or to one's identity within that group. The lowercase "deaf" is used in reference to the audiological condition of not hearing. People who use it to describe themselves might not identify as part of the uppercase Deaf community. In this press release, we use "d/Deaf" to refer to both categories.

ABOUT THE EQUAL RIGHTS CENTER: ERC advances equal access, opportunity, and fair treatment so individuals and communities can thrive. To achieve this mission, ERC uses complementary strategies that support individuals, expose discrimination, promote institutional accountability, prevent unfair treatment, and advance systemic change. Our deepest expertise is in fair housing and disability rights, but we also work in other areas, particularly where civil rights testing can help uncover discrimination and promote accountability. For more information, please visit www.equalrightscenter.org.

ABOUT HANDLEY FARAH & ANDERSON: Handley Farah & Anderson are lawyers who seek to improve the world. Based in Washington, D.C., they fight for: workers deprived of wages, consumers deceived about products, tenants denied access to housing, farmers mistreated by processors, parents deprived of adequate parental leave, investors who were defrauded, small businesses harmed by antitrust violations, persons with disabilities denied access, whistleblowers who uncover fraud, and women and communities of color subject to discrimination.

Cision View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/civil-rights-organization-alleges-major-telehealth-providers-exclude-deaf-and-hard-of-hearing-communities-nationwide-302946019.html

SOURCE Equal Rights Center